LEONARD LUMBER REPORT: THE STRUGGLE BETWEEN WHAT THE LUMBER MARKET WAS AND WHAT IT IS
Recap:
As I write this, I am struggling between what the lumber market was and what it is. It was a low margin high volume structure for a thousand years. In recent years it has turned into a high margin low volume trade. You have to ask which it is today. There have been structural changes to the industry. There was a big consolidation in distribution. A loss of available cut and contraction in production. And most importantly was the change in volatility. Three months into 2023 I’m wondering if we have integrated those changes into the marketplace or need more time. If it has been integrated into the market prices will be range bound. If it has yet to be integrated, then there are higher highs coming.
Markets are efficient when value is defined. A farmer will sell futures if the price is a few pennies over the elevator. It’s called the basis. Over the past few weeks, I have noticed the traders in this industry are reluctant to do a basis trade that will net out a $40 profit after all the expenses. I am not judging. I am just stating one of many issues we have with pricing. The buy side does not trade a $40 gain, nor does the sell side trade a $40 less of a loss. The nature of the trade today will cause more volatility and that volatility will remain until it’s deemed unproductive.
Another aspect of the volatility equation is the fear and greed quotient. Today we are going to redefine it as the fear and fear quotient. The industry is waiting for the other shoe to drop in housing, and it will stay hand to mouth until defined. Last week’s 1.45 starts number was great. I was looking for a 1.1 to 1.2 number coming into spring. The Fed told us that housing would be pushed into a recession. We haven’t seen it. We should all be dancing the tarantella. (Happy St. Joseph’s Day) Instead the big number is all the more reason to practice restraint. Maybe there is a little bit of greed out there too. Why give it back? For whatever the reason, the lumber market will remain underbought.
Technical:
The chart pattern has been flat for almost a year now. It is grinding along the bottom with no end in sight. The market manages a rally every 8 weeks but doesn’t change the pattern. Today the market is sitting on the weekly resistance line from back at the highs of 2022. It’s at 455.00. A close above that area will bring in some buying as signals are set off with the short funds. There are three parts to a cycle today. First is fund short covering followed by the industry buying cash and finished off with spec futures buying. To sum it up, the technicals indicate a market that is $100 away from mediocracy and $200 away from a bull cycle.
NEW CONTRACT:
Lumber Futures Volume & Open Interest
CFTC Commitments of Traders Long Report
https://www.cftc.gov/dea/futures/other_lf.htm
Lumber & Wood Pulp Options
https://www.cmegroup.com/daily_bulletin/current/Section23_Lumber_Options.pdf
About the Leonard Report:
The Leonard Lumber Report is a column that focuses on the lumber futures market’s highs and lows and everything else in between. Our very own, Brian Leonard, risk analyst, will provide weekly commentary on the industry’s wood product sectors.
Brian Leonard
312-761-2636